Projects for Cavity Nesters
Date: Mon, 28 Jan 2002 11:22:06 -0500
To: bluebird-l"at"cornell.edu (BLUEBIRD-L)
From: Tina Phillips cbp6"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Call for projects
Hello nest box monitors,
It has recently come to my attention that nest box monitors
are more than just backyard birders. They are inventors, scientists,
conservationists, outreach specialists, and teachers, among
other things. Over the past few months, I have been continually
amazed at the level of involvement and sophistication of Birdhouse
Network participants and Bluebird-l members. For example, I
have received reports about individual research projects that
participants have conducted to answer a specific question relative
to their boxes. Others are so motivated by nest box monitoring
that they have gone above and beyond the call of duty and started
monitoring programs in their neighborhoods. Still others conduct
sound recordings that may help monitor populations of less common
birds. I could go on and on, but I think you get my point. Some
of these studies are truly scientific in nature and the results
quite interesting.
I am very encouraged by these folks who go the extra mile...not
only do they report nest box data year after year, they are
constantly asking questions of themselves and their boxes in
an effort to improve, redesign, or simply know more about nest
box monitoring and the birds therein.
It occurred to me that the "individual projects"
conducted by these folks ought to be showcased on TBN's web
site so that others might also enjoy reading about their
findings. As a result of this, I am planning on setting aside
several pages in TBN's web site to highlight some of the amazing
efforts nest box monitors have made for the sake of cavity-nesting
birds.
I know there are many of you out there who have done your own
little projects, and I'd like to highlight those as well. Please
note, I am not looking to get pages and pages of nest box data.
While data is valuable in itself, I hope that it is already
accounted for in TBN's database. I am looking for examples of
some type of scientific experiment, no matter how simple in
structure to answer some question regarding nest box monitoring
and cavity-nesting birds. Additionally, I'd like to highlight
significant outreach efforts by nest box monitors who may have
been responsible for setting up neighborhood trails or monitoring
programs.
And finally, if you have something which meets the criteria
above, it must be submitted to me electronically. If you are
unsure about whether something is suitable, feel free to ask
me. I would also encourage submission of photographs, charts
etc., which may lend visual enhancement to the text. Photos
can be sent to me via snail mail if they are not available electronically.
If you would like to submit a project, your name, city, and
state will be listed unless you prefer to remain anonymous.
I would like to get this up on the web site before April, so
if you have something you think would be appropriate, please
send it to me as soon as possible.
If you have any questions about my request, please feel free
to contact me.
I look forward to receiving your projects.
Thanks in advance,
Tina Phillips
The Birdhouse Network
Cornell Lab of Ornithology
159 Sapsucker Woods Rd.
Ithaca, NY 14850
(607)254-2482
cbp6"at"cornell.edu
http://birds.cornell.edu/birdhouse
Date: Mon, 28 Jan 2002 22:49:26 -0800
From: Linda Violett lviolett"at"earthlink.net
Subject: House Training
Linda Violett - Yorba Linda
In the next few weeks, groundwork for an experiment will begin
at the La Mirada site to see if house sparrows can be trained
to avoid boxes even in the absence of bluebird competition.
There will not be enough nesting bluebirds to defend all sites
and, according to log sheets, sparrows begin laying eggs at
La Mirada park in early April.
The first phase of this experiment will be to put a discreet
1/4" blue sticker on the outside face of all La Mirada
boxes near the entry holes and another (larger) sticker on the
inside back of the box. This will be added to the "2002
Test/La Mirada" log sheet as "Phase I."
I have no idea whether this will have any affect, but it is
worth a try. From a sparrow's perspective, they are honored
guests. La Mirada (just like my Yorba Linda trail) is surrounded
by people putting out birdseed and bird boxes. This is an attempt
to communicate to sparrows that they are not welcome in boxes
with decals.
From: "traveldude" traveldude"at"net1plus.com
To: BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu (BLUEBIRD-L)
Subject: on behalf of Tina Phillips [cbp6"at"cornell.edu]
Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2002 17:33:27 -0500
Hi,
Have read your call for projects with interest.. Here are a
couple of projects that I am working that may or may not be
of interest to you..
Reading recently the Bird Emails for a few weeks now I see
a lot of concern about nest boxes overheating in the summer
sun. I see lots of chat about more and more ventilation to try
and keep internal temperatures down.
As a different approach I have built a drainage pipe box with
a huge overhang roof. My thought is it will keep the direct
sun off of the surface of the box when the sun is above 45 degrees
until it sets below 45 degrees in the afternoon. I have also
spaced the roof 1" above the cover of the box so there
will be minimal conducted sun warmth to the interior.. I predict
that the interiors temperature shouldn't rise above the ambient
air. To prove that what I say is real I have purchased remote
thermometers that can read out on a weather station I have up
to 300 feet from the house via built in radio transmitters..
As soon as the weather warms here in Mass. I will install two
remote thermometers, one in the new box with the giant overhang,(16")
and a second one in a control box without the overhang. Also
I found a software package that will take data from my weather
station and allow it to be used with Excel a spreadsheet program..
Automating it should produce credible numbers for the experiment.
Punching more and more ventilation holes in boxes I feel is
an attempt to have breezes or whatever to try and to dissipate
the heat that the sun has produced.. Keeping the box in the
shade seems to be a much better approach.
Recently I also see concerns about eggs freezing in very early
spring..
I think if I find time I will build a box with an aluminum
floor that will be electrically heated.. I'll use a solid state
thermostat so overheating etc. shouldn't be a problem. Aluminum
so the temperature of the entire floor will be controlled and
uniform.. I thought 70-80 degree F? I think the whole project
should come out very inexpensively and extremely easy on an
electric bill.. Ambient temperatures that approach the design
temp of the floor and the heater will go off automatically.
So no heat during warm summer days etc. Low voltage operation
so safety won't be an issue.. Perhaps an external LED so the
cycling of the heater can be observed from a distance too?
Any interest in these projects?
Paul
From: "Fawzi P. Emad femad <at> fpemad <dot> com
To: "BLUEBIRD-L" BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Re: on behalf of Tina Phillips [cbp6"at"cornell.edu]
Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2002 20:02:14 -0500
Hi,Very interesting experiments! I hope you'll run them all.
I am an engineer (electrical) and I'll be happy to consult
with you on the heater and other projects. One thing to
remember while measuring ambient temp. is that there is
a standard to uphold. It has to be done in the shade at
a certain height from the ground, etc. Be sure to uphold
all standards while making measurements...
Fawzi
Fawzi Emad in Laytonsville, Maryland
femad"at"comcast.net
----- Original Message -----
From: traveldude
To: BLUEBIRD-L
Sent: Wednesday, January 30, 2002 5:33 PM
Subject: on behalf of Tina Phillips [cbp6"at"cornell.edu]
...
Date: Fri, 01 Feb 2002 14:25:29 -0500
To: Bluebird-l"at"cornell.edu (BLUEBIRD-L)
From: Tina Phillips cbp6"at"cornell.edu
Subject: New Pilot Study Announcement
Cc: cbc25"at"cornell.edu (Caren B. Cooper)
Dear Eastern Bluebird Monitors:
Is your south-facing birdhouse really warmer than those facing
other directions? Do females in warmer boxes spend less time
incubating? Do warm birdhouses produce more young? This spring
The Birdhouse Network (TBN) is launching a pilot study, partially
funded by a grant from the North American Bluebird Society,
to answer these and other related questions by recording birdhouse
temperatures and incubation schedules of Eastern Bluebirds.
We are looking for people who carefully monitor birdhouses of
Eastern Bluebirds to participate in this pilot project. With
very little extra effort required, your contribution will be
immense! Basically, all you will need to do is attach tiny automated
devices (data loggers) to your birdhouses and in your bird nests,
monitor the birdhouses as you did in previous years, collect
and submit your data to TBN via the web site, and then mail
the data loggers to the Lab at the end of the breeding season.
A more detailed explanation of the study and protocol will be
sent to all participants in the pilot project.
WHAT IS THE PROJECT ABOUT?
In this study we use tiny, automated temperature data loggers
placed in and on birdhouses to collect information concerning
birdhouse temperatures, ambient temperatures, and incubation
patterns. The data loggers look similar to a stack of 4 dimes,
and record time and temperature at specified intervals and store
the data in memory. If you take part, we will distribute data
loggers for you to place in your birdhouses during the 2002
breeding season. After the breeding season, you simply mail
the data loggers back to the Lab of Ornithology and we attach
them to our computers to download the stored data and combine
with the online database. The study has two main objectives:
(1) To obtain data on variation across the country in incubation
patterns in order to better understand the relationship between
incubation effort and clutch size: a relationship that varies
with temperature and geography.
(2) To obtain data on variation across the country in birdhouse
temperatures relative to ambient temperatures. In doing so we
hope to examine the relationship between birdhouse characteristics
(for example, orientation) and birdhouse temperature, and how
those temperatures influence reproductive success. To participate,
you may have to shift the direction of some of your birdhouses.
These results will be important to Bluebird enthusiasts because
we will be able to identify birdhouse characteristics that enhance
reproductive performance and are thus attractive to Bluebirds.
CAN ANYBODY SIGN UP?
In order to sign up for this pilot study, you must meet the
following criteria:
(1) Must be member of The Birdhouse Network during the 2002
breeding season.
(2) Must enter data on the web via TBN's web page.
(3) Must have at least four birdhouses that have been used repeatedly
by Eastern Bluebirds for laying and incubating a clutch. Preferably,
your birdhouses for this study should be within 0.25 mile of
one another, made of BE inch wood, of similar construction
design, and with no special apparatus to alter birdhouse temperatures
(for example, no shade guards, extra insulating wood, roof deflectors,
etc.).
Note: past membership with TBN is not required, but a history
of careful monitoring of Eastern Bluebirds birdhouses is required
and you must join TBN (and submit data online) for the 2002
breeding season.
WILL EVERYONE WHO SIGNS UP GET TO PARTICIPATE?
Unfortunately, limited resources may mean that not everyone
who wants to put data loggers in their birdhouses this year
will be able to. We are asking for ALL interested and qualified
parties to sign up. Whether we can enroll you in the pilot study
however, depends on a balance of our limited resources. We must
balance the (1) amount of additional funding we receive for
the pilot with (2) the geographic location of interested parties.
We will attempt to collect data across as large a region as
possible and from as many willing participants as possible.
If you are not selected for the pilot study this year, don't
be discouraged we hope to expand the study in future years to
include more birdhouses AND more species.
HOW DO I SIGN UP?
If you are interested (or have questions), please email Dr.
Caren Cooper at cbc25"at"cornell.edu
and provide the following information:
(1) Name, address and location (city, state, zipcode) of potential
birdhouses.
(2) indicate whether you are a current member of TBN (if so,
please include your ID number), and if not a current member,
indicate that you are willing to join TBN and contribute data
via our online web page.
(3) for each birdhouse you would like to enroll, indicate the
type of birdhouse (for example, standard rectangular, Peterson,
PVC, etc.), whether Eastern Bluebirds have nested in it previously,
and the type of habitat.
Tina Phillips
The Birdhouse Network
Cornell Lab of Ornithology
159 Sapsucker Woods Rd.
Ithaca, NY 14850
(607)254-2482
cbp6"at"cornell.edu
http://birds.cornell.edu/birdhouse
Date: Sat, 02 Feb 2002 11:42:55 -0600
To: cbp6"at"cornell.edu (Costanza B. Phillips), Bluebird-l"at"cornell.edu
(BLUEBIRD-L)
From: Kate Oschwald bbnestbox"at"1starnet.com
Subject: Re: New Pilot Study Announcement
Cc: cbc25"at"cornell.edu (Caren B. Cooper)
At 02:25 PM 2/1/02 -0500, Tina Phillips wrote:
Dear Eastern Bluebird Monitors:
...
Tina, I realize there may not be a lot of hard data, but Keith
Kridler's posts in the past lead me to believe there is SOME
data out there that already indicates factors like nestbox orientation,
wood thickness, shade, etc., can lower the temperature in a
nestbox.
I started out with all my nestboxes in the full sun well away
from trees as most books instructed and lost clutches of eggs
in two of them due to heat during a particularly hot summer.
(After I made absolutely certain they were abandoned, I checked
the eggs before disposing of them and they were nearly
hard-boiled!)
These nestboxes were already oriented with entrance holes facing
north, since the same books suggested facing them away from
the prevailing winds. They happened to be made of 1/2"
wood, again because I didn't know any better. My other,
thicker, nestboxes, also in the full sun, resulted in successful
fledgings, so I was easiily convinced WITHOUT NUMBERS that thicker
wood was a factor in protecting from heat. I subsequently
placed all nestboxes but one in the shade of trees since this
is an effective way to offer protection without spending any
money.
The single nestbox left in the full sun seemed particularly
attractive to house sparrows so I did not move it, but continued
trapping them. Neither did I make any modifications for
heat, since the occupants weren't in there for very long.
In June a bluebird pair chose this nestbox. I was concerned
about heat, but since this nestbox was reasonably well ventilated
and made of full 1" thick wood, I was not willing to disturb
the nesting birds unnecessarily. After all I had had successful
nestings in that location in previous years, even into August,
with slightly thinner-walled (3/4") nestboxes.
Last July 4 three baby barn swallows were overcome by heat
in their nest under an uninsulated metal roof, and I ended up
fostering them. I measured the temp at the abandoned nest
and it was around 105 -108 F, if I remember correctly.
There was no room above the nest for adding insulation or I
would have at least tacked up some styrofoam above it and let
their parents raise them (after I rehydrated them with some
moist food per my rehabbers instructions) This caused
me to worry anew about the nestbox in the sun that now contained
bluebird eggs only about 50 feet away.
Although some on the list have been successful with adding
various contraptions (even umbrellas!) to active nestboxes I
was more cautious. I spray painted one side of some styrofoam
to approximate the color of the existing roof, and attached
it on top of the roof. I did not even increase the overhang,
but my dial thermometer indicated I reduced the temp in the
nestbox from 103 F to 98 F, (ambient 95 F). Now that a
new nesting season
is upon us I will be adding a larger second roof in the next
few days.
I do not have enough similar nestboxes to participate in the
study, but even if I had a huge trail, I would not be willing
to risk losing any eggs or chicks to extreme heat just for an
"experiment". The study might be interesting
for someone trying to keep their nestboxes a little warmer in
a cold wet spring, but if it continued into the heat of summer
I would be concerned for the little "guinea pigs"
that might be occupying the experimental nestboxes.
Kate Oschwald
Paris, TX
100 mi NE of Dallas
33.6853N 95.6293W
Date: Sat, 02 Feb 2002 11:07:48 -0800
From: Linda Violett lviolett"at"earthlink.net
To: "Bluebird-L"at"cornell.edu" (BLUEBIRD-L) Bluebird-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Re: Pilot Study /Heat
Linda Violett - Yorba Linda, CA
Kate's comments on the heat problems in her area of Texas are
similar to what I've seen here in So. Calif.
For hot southern climates, it would be interesting to know:
1) How many nest failures/abandonements are caused by
heat--monitors putting boxes in full sun and away from trees
(to "protect" them from wrens)
As opposed to:
2) How many nest failures/abandonements are caused by
wrens at boxes near trees.
Kate Oschwald wrote:
I started out with all my nestboxes in the full sun well away
from
...
Date: Mon, 4 Feb 2002 21:56:21 -0600
From: "Frank Navratil Sr" frnavrat"at"concentric.net
Subject: Eastern Bluebird website update
Fellow Bluebird enthusiasts and bird lovers and friends.
I have updated my web site with results of Bluebird birdhouse
trail activities for year 2001.
http://www.concentric.net/~frnavrat
New information:
1) Unusual occurrences... Chickadee nest with 21 eggs... photo.
2) Deterring House Sparrows... Translucent birdhouse as a House
Sparrow deterrent?
3) Deterring House Sparrows... Using Monofilament fishing line...
An update.
4) Personal Bluebird Trail Activity... Summary of fledging and
fledging trends for North Riverside & Wolf Road Prairie
areas (northeast Illinois)...
Activity for each birdhouse.
Do visit!
Frank Navratil Sr.
http://www.concentric.net/~frnavrat
Date: Mon, 04 Feb 2002 21:53:32 -0800
From: Linda Violett lviolett"at"earthlink.net
Subject: Re: Eastern Bluebird website update
Linda Violett - Yorba Linda, Calif.
I, too, have been experimenting with the effects of light as
a possible deterrent for honeybees, wrens and sparrows (in that
order). Instead of translucent material, I've been putting
skylights on the roofs of experimental hanging boxes (can only
be done with boxes in shade) and some boxes have under-the-roof
windows. Pictures of the skylight boxes are at: http://home.earthlink.net/~lviolett/winterroost.html
Keep in mind that the material I've been working with is crystal
clear plexiglas--not just translucent. The bright light
from skylight washes the entire interior of the box plus the
boxes have two entry holes. I don't feel either of these
box styles are safe for boxes exposed to sun and would also
be concerned for heat gain in boxes with translucent material
if exposed to the sun.
Plexiglas does not prevent either wrens or honeybees from using
the boxes. But I do believe it has a slight initial deterrent
factor to birds (not bees) and a surprise element which can
be used to the monitor's benefit. The vast majority of
bluebirds accepted the skylight boxes. My first WEBL eggs
of last season were laid in an experimental skylight box (see
nest: http://home.earthlink.net/~lviolett/claimstraws.html
) but a few pairs hesitated and one pair refused to build until
their old box was hung.
During the mid-season conversion at the golf course trail (sparrow
problems on a previously 1-holed trail), I switched a problem
site to a 2-holed skylight box after bluebirds fledged and sparrows
moved in--the golf course can only be monitored quickly once
per week and sparrows might have already given up the site after
I smashed their eggs, twice. Anyone's guess. See 3rd set of
logs at: http://home.earthlink.net/~lviolett/conversion.html
But I do think light changes (plex/translucent) is well worth
exploring.
I will try a few of my skylight boxes at La Mirada Park (a
newly-acquired sparrow infested park) which will be tracked
on line during 2002. I'm guessing that well-lit boxes
will be similar to the monofilament--may work for a while until
the birds get used to it. This post will only be shared
with this specialized list because I believe more harm than
good will be done if people start playing with well-lit boxes
under sunlit conditions.
Linda Violett
Frank Navratil Sr wrote:
Fellow Bluebird enthusiasts and bird lovers and friends.
...
Date: Tue, 05 Feb 2002 17:17:59 -0500
To: Bluebird-L"at"cornell.edu (BLUEBIRD-L)
From: Tina Phillips cbp6"at"cornell.edu
Subject: New Study Clarifications
We appreciate the comments from those of you interested in
bluebirds and their birdhouses. It is encouraging to see
how well those with birdhouses understand what is potentially
important to bluebirds and concerned enough about research on
bluebirds to take the time to provide input. In our letter
to recruit participants in the pilot study, we tried to be brief
with regards to the details of the project. Unfortunately,
this resulted in many valid worries regarding the pilot study
and quite a bit of skepticism regarding what we can gain from
the pilot study. In order to address the concerns expressed
on the list serve, we will try to explain the pertinent details
of the study.
The pilot study has two main components: (1) to collect data
on incubation patterns and (2) to collect data on birdhouse
temperatures. Clearly there is more interest and concerns
among our participants with regard to birdhouse temperatures,
so we elaborate on that aspect of the project here.
As pointed out by The Texas Bluebird Society, almost every
characteristic of a birdhouse will affect its temperature.
The focus of our pilot study is birdhouse orientation and, as
was correctly pointed out, we need to control for other factors
affecting temperature. Fortunately, our protocol does
address this need. The protocol for this pilot involves
each participant (using data loggers) to monitor the temperature
in 4 of their birdhouses used by Eastern Bluebirds. It
would be the responsibility of each participant to use 4 birdhouses
that were as similar to each other as possible in as many characteristics
as possible, except with respect to orientation. Each
box would face one of 4 cardinal directions. Because each
participant knows their birdhouses better than we do, we will
ask participants to control for these other characteristics
in the best way possible for their site. Within each site,
participants will also have a data logger to measure the ambient
temperature of the site. In that way, we will compare
temperatures inside each birdhouse relative to temperatures
outside each birdhouse at each site. Therefore, at any
give location and/or ambient temperature, we can answer the
question: all else being equal among birdhouses, how much does
orientation matter? And, because we hope to have participants
all over eastern North America, we can see how much that answer
varies geographically. We do not need to have all participants
control for birdhouse characteristics in exactly the same way.
We asked for information about certain birdhouse characteristics
simply to get an idea of the types of birdhouses that might
be involved in the pilot study.
To address the valid concerns about overheating, we will include
birdhouses that use heat-reducing devices of any sort as long
as ALL 4 birdhouses in
the pilot study at a given site have identical heat-reducing
devices.
Another point we feel important to emphasize is that we try
to measure the observed, underlying pattern. Of course,
with all the data we are given, there will be what is referred
to as 'noise' or extreme variation from the normal pattern.
In order to reduce the amount of noise and make it easier to
detect the pattern, we need as large a database as possible.
One purpose of a pilot study is to measure the amount of variation
in the system of interest so we can determine sample sizes necessary
for future research. This is why we need as many participants
as possible in the pilot study!
Finally, there were some concerns expressed about the reliability
of our participants. As with all of our Citizen Science
projects, we trust the data provided by participants.
Everyone at some point may make errors in recording numbers
or in entering the data on-line. That is part of the 'noise'
and is something addressed in statistical analyses.
We hope this addresses the concerns expressed so far.
Please don't hesitate to ask more questions or express your
concerns if you are considering signing up for this pilot study.
We encourage you to sign up quickly so we can get data
loggers to participants before the nesting season. If
you are interested, please contact us as soon as possible.
Thank you,
Caren Cooper cbc25"at"cornell.edu
Tina Phillips cbp6"at"cornell.edu
Tina Phillips
The Birdhouse Network
Cornell Lab of Ornithology
159 Sapsucker Woods Rd.
Ithaca, NY 14850
(607)254-2482
cbp6"at"cornell.edu
http://birds.cornell.edu/birdhouse
Date: Tue, 5 Feb 2002 20:41:46 -0600
From: "Frank Navratil Sr" frnavrat"at"concentric.net
Subject: clear plastic covered open top birdhouses
Linda Violett & NHSK group,
Here is some more information about experiments with clear
plastic covered open top bird houses. Loren Hughes sent me an
email describing her efforts. Contact her if you are interested
in seeing a photo of her birdhouse design. (I have a copy also).
+++++ original email from Loran ++++++
Hi, my name is Loren Hughes, and am the former chairperson
of the IBP, I wanted to let you know that we are very
disappointed in the fact that the IBP is no longer active. The
reasons we resigned are personal, but didn't think they would
no longer be active. The purpose of the IBP was to promote the
nesting and increase the bluebird population. With this in mind,
we are planning to start a bluebird society, at the present
called East Central Bluebird Society. We will have an organizational
meeting sometime in April. We will be mailing notices
I have built a nest box, that has worked for me, and have several
out to be tested. Sparrows looked it over several time and left
it, a bluebird moved in and nested. The secret is the
Plexiglas on the top, with a hinged cover, that when the
bluebird had her nest half built, I closed the cover and she
proceeded to finish her nest and raised her babies. The box
is the one board box, that I designed and NABS approved.
I make it into a kit, and it is used in workshops. I am attaching
the photos of it so you can see how it is made. Try it and see
if it will work for you.
Keep; up the good work, and keep em flying===
Loren Hughes
1234 Tucker Beach Rd.
Paris, IL 61944
217-463-7175
suziq"at"comwares
++++++++++ my (Frank Navratil) reply to Lorn +++++
Nice hearing from you Loren,
Thanks for attaching the photographs. Your hinged second roof
is an interesting solution. This design and its sequence
of use (cover after Bluebird builds nest) may prove to be very
House Sparrow resistant. Only time will tell of course.
I have played with a similar Plexiglas top on one birdhouse
(a wood Kentucky slot style) in my backyard. Over the
years I made modifications:
1) The original house was occupied by House Sparrows immediately.
2) After a couple of years I cut a 4 inch hole in the roof
of the bird house and put a new roof about 1 inch above the
old roof to keep rain and sun out. My thinking being that the
hole in the top would discourage House Sparrows. They still
nested.
3) Next I removed the roof above the 4 inch hole and placed
clear Plexiglas over the 4 inch hole as you have done to keep
rain out. For about three years now, the House Sparrows
have avoided nesting in it. Like you, I have watched House Sparrows
check out this birdhouse with its Plexiglas roof but never nest
in it.
4) I figured that maybe some day I would try this concept for
hanging birdhouses where the sun burning through the roof would
not be a problem. Never got to that project.
I also cut a 4 inch hole in a second Kentucky slot style birdhouse.
This one was mounted on my garage wall about one foot below
the garage roof the garage roof extended far enough so that
rain and overhead sun were excluded. House Sparrows never nested
in that birdhouse. A new garage terminated that experiment.
So, I am saying that my observations of two birdhouses in my
backyard tend to support your design as being House Sparrow
resistant. Good Show! Good thinking! Good luck!
Frank Navratil Sr.
http://www.concentric.net/~frnavrat
Date: Wed, 6 Feb 2002 09:29:17 -0600
From: "Keith & Sandy Kridler" kridler"at"1starnet.com
Subject: Re: clear plastic covered open top birdhouses
The Bauldry nestbox used in the 60's and 70's had a 4"
hole cut in the roof protected with wire to keep out predators
and still had sparrows nesting in it in some regions. The "raised
roof" also used in the 60's and 70's with a roof above
an open wire protected top also worked for some areas and failed
miserably in others. When sparrows were found nesting in boxes
during the 70's it was recommended that the nest be removed
and the top of the box be removed to make the sparrows leave.
It was found that often the sparrow would simply build in the
open top box since they are weaver finches and used to nesting
in the open branches of trees in many areas of the country.
Removing the door or side was recommended and once again some
sparrows continued to nest as they will in open shelves designed
for robins. Changing a box is what often makes the sparrow to
move on and we don't know what each individual really is looking
for in a nest site. All options should be tried as one is bound
to work at making hem leave and finding another mate or nest
sites as there are millions of options available to a House
Sparrow. KK
Date: Wed, 06 Feb 2002 18:53:30 -0800
From: Linda Violett lviolett"at"earthlink.net
Subject: Re: clear plastic covered open top birdhouses
Thanks for sharing the posts (I'm interested in seeing the
photo). This could be interesting--La Mirada is a sparrow-infested
test site for 2-hole boxes this year. But sparrows will
absolutely move into the 2-holers if they are without challenge,
so La Mirada would be an excellent site to test effects of skylights
vs. sparrows at the unchallenged boxes.
Within 60 days we will know--one way or the other--if sparrows
will nest in skylight boxes, or if there is any hesitation and
the timing. The eleven boxes at La Mirada are now all
solid roofed boxes and I plan to see if sparrows can be trained
to avoid marked boxes. But I can work in the skylight
tests up front at the start of the season; I have at least half
dozen skylight boxes on hand and can pull a few more of my trail
if needed.
If bluebirds claim a site, it will stay a solid roof to keep
the 2-hole box test separate from the skylight feature.
But we can wait until sparrows start building a nest in unchallenged
boxes to switch to skylights . . . the results will be tracked
weekly on the 2002 Test page.
Sound interesting?
Any suggestions?
Linda Violett
Frank Navratil Sr wrote:
Linda Violett & NHSK group,
Sparrows looked it over several time and left it, a bluebird
moved
in and nested. The secret is the Plexiglas on the top,
with a hinged cover,
that when the bluebird had her nest half built, I closed the
cover and she
proceeded to finish her nest and raised her babies. The box
is the one
board box, that I designed and NABS approved. I make it into
a kit, and it
is used in workshops. I am attaching the photos of it so you
can see how it
is made. Try it and see if it will work for you.
Keep; up the good work, and keep em flying===
Loren Hughes
1234 Tucker Beach Rd.
Paris, IL 61944
217-463-7175
suziq"at"comwares
Date: Wed, 6 Feb 2002 22:16:57 -0600
From: "Keith & Sandy Kridler" kridler"at"1starnet.com
Subject: training sparrows
OK guys I really am sober! What if you taught the trapped sparrows
to actually FEAR bluebirds....What if you took a gallon glass
jar and pasted color photos of bluebirds facing in towards the
inside of the jar and then dropped your trapped sparrows into
the jar shaking it violently enough that the sparrows would
think the bluebirds just kicked the tar out of them....Release
them so that they can go tell the rest of the sparrows that
"Super Bluebirds" are attacking. There are all kinds
of possibilities along these lines....:-) KK
Date: Wed, 6 Feb 2002 23:52:22 EST
From: KCBSP"at"aol.com
Subject: Re: training sparrows
In a Message dated 2/6/2002 11:20:01 PM Eastern Standard Time,
kridler"at"1starnet.com writes:
OK guys I really am sober! What if you taught the trapped
sparrows to
...
Hey Keith!!!
I believe you're sober.. but sure why not try that????
Maybe we could paste weapons on the wings too???? dress
them in ninja suits????? You are too much!! If you really
try this let me know. hee hee Maybe we can
just send lightening to their nest box, huh???
Kathy
Date: Thu, 07 Feb 2002 05:53:33 -0800
From: Linda Violett lviolett"at"earthlink.net
Subject: Re: training sparrows
Linda Violett - Yorba Linda, Calif.
Keith, you cheated and jumped ahead of the rest of the class
by reading my "House Training Project: below La Mirada
2002 Test! See:
http://home.earthlink.net/~lviolett/test2002.html
Color association: Blue (bluebirds)
Bluebird photos included
Will it have any affect? Who knows, but it is worth a
try and I'm not seeing enough ideas that are GOOD for bluebirds.
Everyone seems to be headed in the direction of making a box
too awful for the sparrows to use. Boxes are being touted as
a success in the sparrow fight without counting the bluebird
losses because the box is too small or too hot . . . too dangerous.
There are other alternatives to be found. Time is running
out for those in rural areas who think they can move boxes away
from sparrows; and those who depend on trapping will end up
the same as the man bailing water from a sinking ship.
Keith & Sandy Kridler wrote:
OK guys I really am sober! What if you taught the trapped sparrows
to
...
Date: Thu, 7 Feb 2002 22:58:15 -0600
From: "Jim McLochlin" bluebirdbox"at"cox.net
Subject: RE: Digest Number 72
I guess I must be trying to live in a surreal world when I
describe a box as a success if it fledges bluebirds.
Jim McLochlin
Omaha, NE
41.279N -96.060W
The Audubon Society of Omaha = http://audubon-omaha.org/
The Bluebird Box = http://audubon-omaha.org/bbbox/index.htm
Omaha Web Solutions = http://www.omahawebsol.com
-----Original Message-----
Date: Thu, 07 Feb 2002 05:53:33 -0800
From: Linda Violett lviolett"at"earthlink.net
Subject: Re: training sparrows
...
Date: Mon, 18 Feb 2002 14:50:19 -0500
To: BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu (BLUEBIRD-L)
From: "Caren B. Cooper" cbc25"at"cornell.edu
Subject: More needed for Cornell pilot study
The Birdhouse Network is CALLING FOR MORE PARTICIPANTS IN PILOT
STUDY OF FEMALE INCUBATION RHYTHMS. YOU NEED ONLY ONE BIRDHOUSE
TO PARTICIPATE
Earlier this month, we announced a pilot study using small
temperature data loggers to address questions regarding both
birdhouse orientation and female incubation rhythms. One requirement
to participate was at least 4 birdhouses of similar design and
location. Thanks to those who volunteered, we now have participants
across the US to conduct a good pilot project to address questions
regarding the influence of orientation on birdhouse temperatures.
However, we will still welcome more participants from under-represented
regions, namely NC, VA, PA, OH, IN, the New England area, and
Canada!
Also, since there might be more people that want to participate
but have fewer than 4 birdhouses, we want to extend our invitation.
We need more participants to better address questions regarding
female incubation rhythms. For this part of the study, you only
need at least ONE birdhouse that consistently has Eastern Bluebirds
nesting. To participate, you monitor your birdhouse as in previous
years, but also place one data logger on the inside of the birdhouse
(attached to a wall or roof), one data logger outside the birdhouse
(attached to the floor), and one data logger carefully placed
within the nest material. Nest temperature fluctuates with the
arrival and departure of the female. Recording nest temperature
over time allows us to estimate the duration of each female's
on- and off- the nest bouts. This is the same basic protocol
as those with 4 or more birdhouses, except alterations (i.e.,
changing orientation) to your birdhouse(s) are not necessary.
The Deadline for signing up for both the comprehensive (orientation
and incubation rhythm) and the incubation rhythm pilot is Tuesday,
February 26th. The breeding season is beginning so we need to
have a complete list of those interested in participating in
order to divide up our data loggers as equally as possible across
the breeding range of Eastern Bluebirds.
If you would like to participate or find out more information,
please contact Dr. Caren Cooper at cbc25"at"cornell.edu. Please
provide:
(1) Your name and the location (city, state, zip code) and
number of potential birdhouses.
(2) Please indicate whether you are a current member of TBN,
and if not a current member, indicate that you are willing to
join TBN in order to contribute data via our online web page.
Thanks for your help!
Cheers,
Caren Cooper
Date: Wed, 6 Mar 2002 12:16:05 -0800 (PST)
From: The Doctor sytyf"at"yahoo.com
Subject: My 2 cents, nickel and quarter' s worth
To: BLUEBIRD BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Hi all,
Several posts concerning HOSP attacks in nestboxes. Four years
ago, I bought my first nestbox because the father of an acquaintence
made them. He bugged me endlessly to buy a nestbox almost as
a favor to him for his father. I remember that he told me not
to expect Bluebirds for at least a year. I can't even remember
what motivated me to put the nestbox up. Although I had raised
Bobwhite quail for several years already, I couldn't tell the
difference between the majority of birds if my life depended
on it. I can't even say if I remember ever seeing a Bluebird
in my lifetime. Well, as luck would have it, a Bluebird pair
nested with Mrs. Bluebird laying the first egg one week after
I set up that first nestbox.
I never heard of NABS or the Cornell Bluebird-L list so I tried
futilely to draw on my experience with quail. I quickly determined
that Quail and Bluebirds were like apples and oranges. I began
learning about HOSP and Starlings. I then realized that I had
a major HOSP problem on my modest trail. Thinking back about
it all, I did many things contrary to 'conventional wisdom'
because I did not know what 'conventional wisdom' was regarding
cavity nesting birds. I never bought another nestbox.... I began
designing and constructing my own. Anyway, here's where I will
finally get to the point. My nestbox design has evolved over
the years basically to protect the native cavity nesting birds.
Phase I : slotted holes sometimes 3 inches wide by 1 7/16"
high. Large cavities sometimes more than 30 square inches. A
design focused on giving the adult Blue enough room to escape
and not get cornered by the HOSP.
Phase II : monofilament line.
Phase III : The 'rear window' and 'vertigo' nestbox designs.
I actually witnessed Blues escape from a Phase I nestbox on
two seperate occasions. 'Rear window' will hopefully keep the
HOSP from entering altogether and 'vertigo' & Phase II nestbox
designs will hopefully deter the HOSP from entering the nestbox
fearlessly. I utilize a combination of all three designs in
several of my nestboxes.
I have been a part of this list off and on for about a year
now. The knowledge and experience here is priceless however,
there is alot to be said for the 'school of hard knocks' too.
Certainly, active and/or passive HOSP control extends outside
of the nestbox however, I think the nestbox is the point of
focus. Too many times I hear discussions about the size and
shape of the hole or the EXACT height from the floor etc, etc
etc, etc. I think that we should all be encouraged to adapt
the basic fundamentals to something that works on our own trails.
Have a great day
Bob Sitarski a.k.a. The Doctor
Clay County Illinois and Jackson County Indiana
Date: Fri, 05 Jul 2002 11:11:59 -0700
To: BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
From: "Amber J. Keyser" keyser"at"arches.uga.edu
Subject: Why Adult Birds Die - NEED HELP WITH RESEARCH
Hello,
I am the research coordinator for the Prescott Bluebird Recovery
Project. I am studying causes of death in adult bluebirds. I
am writing to ask for help from all of you dedicated bluebird
folks. Here is the information I need:
1. The number of boxes that you monitor.
2. The number of boxes that have had bluebird activity.
3. The number of dead adults you have found in or around boxes
(preferably # male and # female). 4. Cause of death if known
5. If possible, I would like this information broken down by
year.
I suggest that you email me directly (keyser"at"arches.uga.edu)
rather than the entire listserv. I will summarize all the information
that I collect and will post that summary to the listserv.
Thank you for all your help!
Amber Keyser
************************************************************
Amber J. Keyser
Ph.D. Candidate, Department of Genetics, University of Georgia
Visiting Graduate Student, Department of Biological Sciences,
Washington State University -- Vancouver Research Coordinator,
Prescott Bluebird Recovery Project, www.prescottbluebird.com
5838 SW Vermont Street
Portland, OR 97219
503-293-3290 voice
503-860-7567 mobile
530-733-3321 e-Fax
From: Caren B. Cooper,
cbc25"at"cornell.edu
Sent: Monday, February 23, 2004 1:51 PM
Subject: Temperature Incubation Study Needs
YOU!
YOU ARE INVITED TO PARTICIPATE..............
The Birdhouse Network (TBN) is looking for volunteers to help in a study of incubation
temperatures of Eastern, Western, and Mountain Bluebirds. The study utilizes
dime-sized temperature recorders (data loggers) that were purchased with help
from NABS. The data loggers permit researchers to infer incubation rhythms
based on temperatures fluctuations in the nest cup. This is a fun and interesting
study and, by participating, you will discover the temperatures in your nest
boxes! Participation does require a level of comfort in using a computer,
but past participants have quickly learned how to use the data loggers with ease. Past
participants are encouraged to sign up again!
As in previous years, volunteers use two data loggers per box - one to measure nest
box temperatures while the other simultaneously measures nest
cup temperature during egg-laying and incubation. To learn more
about the theories guiding the study, visit < www.birds.cornell.edu/birdhouse > and
click on Eastern Bluebird Incubation Rhythms. You can also visit < www.birds.cornell.edu/publications/birdscope/Summer2002/Rhythm_Bluebirds.html > to
learn about the types of information the data loggers provide.
MINIMUM REQUIREMENT FOR PARTICIPATION
*Participants must become members of TBN (Membership is discounted to $12 for
members of any bluebird society and includes an annual subscription to the Cornell
Lab of Ornithology's quarterly publication Birdscope, a welcome packet, and access
to online data entry, storage, and summaries).
*Participants must be committed to keeping accurate records and entering their
nest-box observations via TBN's online data entry site.
*Participants must have access to a computer running Windows in order to program
and download data from the data loggers.
*Participants must have access to e-mail in order to send temperature data to
Cornell.
*Participants must monitor some boxes that generally have bluebirds.
*Participants must monitor some boxes (with bluebirds) closely enough to estimate
first egg date, determine clutch size, estimate hatch date, estimate whether
all eggs hatched on same day or not, and determine the number of unhatched eggs.
We recommend that boxes be monitored about every four days.
If you would like to participate, please email Marilyn Moskel (mlm47"at"cornell.edu)
to join TBN and be sure to indicate that you would like to register for the Incubation
Study. Once the breeding season gets underway in your area, we will send
detailed instructions that will guide you through the use of data loggers, along
with the necessary equipment, and data collection cards.
If you are interested, contact TBN now!
Marilyn L. Moskal
email: mlm47"at"cornell.edu
159 Sapsucker Woods Rd
Cornell Lab of Ornithology
Ithaca, NY 14850
Website: www.birds.cornell.edu/birdhouse
|