Purple Martins and Bluebirds
(Part 2)
Date: Mon, 15 Apr 2002 20:35:58 -0700 (PDT)
From: The Doctor sytyf"at"yahoo.com
Subject: Anyone help with a PUMA ? on this list?
To: BLUEBIRD BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Hello all,
Mr Jack Wilson and I have had great success with PUMA. Jack
has quietly had much success with PUMA for 20 years now. In
the last three years since Jack has decided to mentor me, we
have gone from 40 to 88 gourds at Jack's residence. Fearing
that we are putting all of our eggs into one basket so to speak
by expanding Jack's colony, we have decided to start new colonies
at two locations each about 3/8 ofa mile from Jack's. We put
up 8 gourds at each new location less than two weeks ago which
was about 3 weeks after Jack's established colony already saw
about 10 PUMA return.
To our surprise, on both Saturday and Monday, male and female
PUMA are showing up at both new sites. Everything needs to be
perfect to start a new colony and unfortunately neither Jack
or I know how to make things perfect. I have posed this ? on
the forum on website purplemartin.org. Should we be trying to
start a new PUMA colony using gourds with the crescent shaped
(starling resistant) entrance holes?. Although the holes seem
to be very effective against starlings the PUMA seem not to
like them either,
Have a good day
Bob Sitarski a.k.a The Doctor
Jackson County Indiana ( 385244N 086023W )
& Clay County Illinois ( 384008N 0882908W )
Date: Mon, 15 Apr 2002 20:36:32 -0700 (PDT)
From: The Doctor sytyf"at"yahoo.com
Subject: Anyone help with a PUMA ? on this list?
To: BLUEBIRD BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Hello all,
Mr Jack Wilson and I have had great success with PUMA. Jack
has quietly had much success with PUMA for 20 years now. In
the last three years since Jack has decided to mentor me, we
have gone from 40 to 88 gourds at Jack's residence. Fearing
that we are putting all of our eggs into one basket so to speak
by expanding Jack's colony, we have decided to start new colonies
at two locations each about 3/8 ofa mile from Jack's. We put
up 8 gourds at each new location less than two weeks ago which
was about 3 weeks after Jack's established colony already saw
about 10 PUMA return.
To our surprise, on both Saturday and Monday, male and female
PUMA are showing up at both new sites. Everything needs to be
perfect to start a new colony and unfortunately neither Jack
or I know how to make things perfect. I have posed this ? on
the forum on website purplemartin.org. Should we be trying to
start a new PUMA colony using gourds with the crescent shaped
(starling resistant) entrance holes?. Although the holes seem
to be very effective against starlings the PUMA seem not to
like them either,
Have a good day
Bob Sitarski a.k.a The Doctor
Jackson County Indiana ( 385244N 086023W )
& Clay County Illinois ( 384008N 0882908W )
From: "Dottie, Hickory Hollow, Brown County, Indiana"
yumyumkatts"at"voyager.net
To: sytyf"at"yahoo.com, "BLUEBIRD" BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Re:O/T Anyone help with a PUMA ? on this list?
Date: Mon, 15 Apr 2002 22:50:34 -0500
I have a modified Purple Martin house and two crescent shaped
supergourds hanging from the Martin house on "arms".
My outfit is down by our lake. No big trees near it and not
far from the house. I'm still waiting for Purple Martins to
come. I don't think the flock is here yet. I went by a huge
gourd colony today that is only a few miles from me and didn't
see any Martins there.
Have you looked at Dr. Dan's protocol on the PM Forum?
Dottie, Hickory Hollow
Brown County, Indiana
(50 miles south of Indianapolis)
----- Original Message -----
From: The Doctor
To: BLUEBIRD
Sent: Monday, April 15, 2002 10:36 PM
Subject: Anyone help with a PUMA ? on this list?
...
From: "Bill Darnell" bdarnel3"at"bellsouth.net
To: sytyf"at"yahoo.com, "BLUEBIRD" BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Re: Anyone help with a PUMA ? on this list?
Date: Tue, 16 Apr 2002 06:13:44 -0500
Doctor, I may be able to help some. I have a three year old
colony which has grown from three pairs the first year, to 23
pairs last year, More are starting their nests this year.
Since this list is for bluebirds mainly, should we take this
off list? I would love to discuss these lovely birds with you!
Bill TN
Hello all,
Mr Jack Wilson and I have had great success with PUMA. Jack
has quietly had much success with PUMA for 20 years now. In
the last three years since Jack has decided to mentor me, we
have gone from 40 to 88 gourds at Jack's residence. Fearing
that we are putting all of our eggs into one basket so to speak
by expanding Jack's colony, we have decided to start new colonies
at two locations each about 3/8 ofa mile from Jack's. We put
up 8 gourds at each new location less than two weeks ago which
was about 3 weeks after Jack's established colony already saw
about 10 PUMA return. To our surprise, on both Saturday and
Monday, male and female PUMA are showing up at both new sites.
Everything needs to be perfect to start a new colony and unfortunately
neither Jack or I know how to make things perfect. I have posed
this ? on the forum on website purplemartin.org. Should we be
trying to start a new PUMA colony using gourds with the crescent
shaped (starling resistant) entrance holes?. Although the holes
seem to be very effective against starlings the PUMA seem not
to like them either,
Have a good day
Bob Sitarski a.k.a The Doctor
Jackson County Indiana ( 385244N 086023W )
& Clay County Illinois ( 384008N 0882908W )
From: "Bill Darnell" bdarnel3"at"bellsouth.net
To: sytyf"at"yahoo.com
Cc: "Bluebirds" BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu (BLUEBIRD-L)
Subject: Re: Anyone help with a PUMA ? on this list?
Date: Tue, 16 Apr 2002 06:32:35 -0500
Here is an answer from the Purple Martin forum by Chuck Abare
to someone who asked almost the same question:
I'm surprised to see this almost exact same question and scenario
twice
in less than 24 hours. I got one very similar from another hopeful
last night from my web page. Actually, it's not an uncommon
question and what I did some time ago so as to not have to type
the same answer over and over again I made a list of the TOP
5 things that a new hopeful can do to make their site more noticeable
and, in your case, more favorable for PM's. Start at the top
and work your way down. See if there's something here that you
might have missed. Sure hope it helps.
1. HOUSING LOCATED IN MOST ACCESSIBLE AREA OF YOUR PROPERTY.
This means, open flyways, away from trees, bushed, fences, hedges
or other obstacles that could allow hawks or other predators
the chance to ambush or attack the housing.
2. DEEP COMPARTMENTS. Housing with small compartments just
doesn't afford any measure of safety for martins (regardless
of what anybody tells you) and as recent research has shown,
99% of the time they will choose housing with the deeper compartments.
That also means at least 10" diameter gourds if they are
used.
3. WHITE HOUSING. Make sure your housing is painted white,
not only to help attract them, but to keep them cool in the
summer.
4. ELIMINATE NESTING COMPETITORS. If you have starlings and
sparrows also investigating your martin housing, then do what
you have to, to eliminate them. Crescent entrances work for
starlings, traps for sparrows. Shooting works for both if permissible
in your area.
5. LANDLORD PRESENCE. This means YOU need to be seen by your
martins, even if you have to walk out of your way. DO NOT be
afraid to go near your martins. You have my word, an active
landlord will have many more martins and happier moments than
a passive landlord.
Chuck Abare, Athens, AL
Bill--TN
Hello all,
Mr Jack Wilson and I have had great success with PUMA. Jack
has quietly had much success with PUMA for
...
From: "Kellams, Dina M" dmkellam"at"indiana.edu
To: bluebird-l"at"cornell.edu (BLUEBIRD-L)
Subject: RE: Multiple BB Nests Built By One Pair?
Date: Tue, 23 Apr 2002 10:51:02 -0500
It's funny that this has come up because yesterday I observed
my male EABL going into my neighbor's Purple Martin House, which
came as a BIG surprise to me - I didn't think a Martin House
would be attractive to them!
Dina
Lawrence Co., Indiana
From: "Dottie, Hickory Hollow, Brown County, Indiana"
yumyumkatts"at"voyager.net
To: "Bluebird L" BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: O/T--BINGO SY's
Date: Wed, 15 May 2002 08:43:28 -0500
BINGO!
About four SY's came swooping over about 8am this morning.
I had the Dawn Song playing. When I saw them, I went out on
the deck and walked around and even waved to them. They stayed
about five minutes or so-swooping and looking everything over--even
me. They got a good look of all I have to offer.
Then they flew over the tree tops towards Joe's house. Be on
the lookout, Joe.
Dottie, Hickory Hollow
Brown County, Indiana
(50 miles south of Indianapolis)
Lat: 39.371N Lon: 86.261W Zone 5 Elevation: 680 ft
Date: Wed, 15 May 2002 10:11:29 -0400
From: "Pat Haught" PAHaught"at"mail.wvu.edu
To: Bluebird-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: carolina chickadees
Hi All, What do carolina chickadee chicks eat? We have 6 chicks.
Their parents visit the feeders and suet cakes. Do they feed
the chicks grain and suet? They aren't insect eaters or are
they? Just curious. Thanks in advance, Patty in WV
From: "Randy Jones" randyj"at"enter.net
To: yumyumkatts"at"voyager.net, "Bluebird L" BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Re: O/T--BINGO SY's
Date: Wed, 15 May 2002 10:14:39 -0400
What's an SY?
Randy Jones
Lehigh County Coordinator
Bluebird Society of PA
----- Original Message -----
From: Dottie, Hickory Hollow, Brown County, Indiana
To: Bluebird L
Sent: Wednesday, May 15, 2002 9:43 AM
Subject: O/T--BINGO SY's
...
From: "Dottie, Hickory Hollow, Brown County, Indiana"
yumyumkatts"at"voyager.net
To: "Bluebird L" BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: O/T SY Purple Martins
Date: Wed, 15 May 2002 09:54:54 -0500
Just a little info about Purple Martins for those of you who
may be interested. They are a "people bird". That's
why I went out on the deck this morning so they could see me.
I'm hoping to get a colony this year. I have a Martin house
up and two supergourds under that. However, I think I will need
to move my Martin house rig up closer to my home. Martins feel
less threatened by predators if they are near people.
The Purple Martin web site is: www.purplemartin.org
It is a great site similar to our Bluebird Box. The Forum is
neat also but is set up differently from Bluebird-L.
A couple of other folks, Joe included, and myself are starting
a Purple Martin Club here. We will probably call it Central
Indiana Purple Martin Asso. Our first meeting is May 20th.
Dottie, Hickory Hollow
Brown County, Indiana
(50 miles south of Indianapolis)
Lat: 39.371N Lon: 86.261W Zone 5 Elevation: 680 ft
From: "Dottie, Hickory Hollow, Brown County, Indiana"
yumyumkatts"at"voyager.net
To: "Gilliam, Jay" jay.gilliam"at"pioneer.com
Cc: "Bluebird L" BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Re: O/T SY Purple Martins
Date: Wed, 15 May 2002 10:13:29 -0500
"Hi Dottie---
What does "SY" stand for??Thanks...Jay Gilliam"
SY stands for Second Year Martins. They start the new colonies.
After the Martin babies are fledged, the mom and pop take them
around the area to show them possible nesting sites for the
next year. SY Martins don't go back to where they were born--they
don't intermingle (if that's the way to say it). Only the moms
and dads go back to the same place each year. They are a very
faithful bird.
Anyway, if you put a Martin house up this year, you may not
get Martins until the next year. The SY Martins need to see
your housing when mom and dad are taking them around.
Dottie, Hickory Hollow
Brown County, Indiana
(50 miles south of Indianapolis)
Lat: 39.371N Lon: 86.261W Zone 5 Elevation: 680 ft
From: "Cinda J. Salisbury" cjs"at"cvns.net
To: BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Purple Martin Question
Date: Sun, 19 May 2002 17:37:33 -0700
I forgot that I can ask you guys about Purple Martins. I look
in on that Forum as well. Everyone there keeps telling me that
I need to be patient. I have a new box I just put up this month.
There is absolutely no interest except for HOSP. I've only seen
a few Martins fly over the area. What is going on here? My husband
is involved in dairy bulls/cows and covers a large territory.
He goes to many dairy farms, and tells me that there are very
few occupied houses this year. What gives??? Have any of you
experienced this?
Cinda....South-central Pa. - Shippensburg
From: "Bill Darnell" bdarnel3"at"bellsouth.net
To: cjs"at"cvns.net, BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Re: Purple Martin Question
Date: Sun, 19 May 2002 16:40:28 -0500
It is hard for a Southern (Tennessee) Martin Landlord to understand
what is going on in the northern states. The weather is one
thing. I am beginning to hear heart rending stories of hatchling
Martins dying in the cold in MN, MI, and across the northern
states.
If you are using a box only, I recommend hanging gourds from
the four bottom corners of the box. I used all gourds until
this season, and built a nice 14 room box. I have one pair using
the box, with all four gourds under it occupied. The first season
is the hardest. It is like the old adage, "The rich get
richer---"
Once you get the first couple of pairs, it will get easy. In
2000, my first year, I got three pairs. In 2001, this increased
to 23 pairs, and this year, we have over 52 pairs now! Granted,
it is much easier here in TN than PA, but you will get them,
just keep trying and keep the Starlings and Sparrows at bay!
The sub-adult birds are still filtering in down here, so you
still have some time this year.
Take care,
Bill
I forgot that I can ask you guys about Purple Martins. I look
in on
...
Date: Mon, 20 May 2002 20:05:46 -0400
From: Michael Fuller michaelf"at"ia4u.net
To: BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Martins
We've had bluebirds for three years on our acre. We have also
seen purple martins in the neighborhood and flying over our
property so we have considered placing a Martin House in our
yard. Has anyone had problems with martins driving away their
bluebirds or trying to take over their house? I'd like to know
before we attract more martins.
Thanks,
Michael
From: "Bill Darnell" bdarnel3"at"bellsouth.net
To: michaelf"at"ia4u.net, BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Re: Martins
Date: Mon, 20 May 2002 20:07:48 -0500
Martins will not take over your bluebird houses, or cause them
any problems. It might happen the other way around, though.
If bluebirds bond to the house or gourds you put up for the
Martins, they can keep the SY (second year, or sub-adult) birds
from nesting. They won't be a problem to Martins that have site
fidelity, that is, Martins which have bonded to the site. (Making
myself real clear! :-))
Go to www.purplemartin.org and read the archives, and especially,
the FAQ.
Bill
TN
We've had bluebirds for three years on our acre. We have also
seen
...
From: CookinMedic"at"aol.com
Date: Mon, 17 Jun 2002 09:49:11 EDT
Subject: Bluebirds in Purple Martin house
To: BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
I have bluebirds nesting in my Purple Martin Condo. Has anyone
heard or seen of this before?
C. Rondeau
Gloucester, VA
From: hubertrap"at"webtv.net (Joe Huber)
Date: Mon, 17 Jun 2002 11:36:41 -0400 (EDT)
To: CookinMedic"at"aol.com, BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Re: Bluebirds in Purple Martin house
Yes mine done that for several years in late summer for their
last nest. This makes it hard to attract martins Joe Huber
Charter member NABS, Charter member OBS, Life member OBS Joe
Huber hubertrap"at"webtv.net
http://community.webtv.net/hubertrap/HOUSESPARROWCONTROL
http://community.webtv.net/hubertrap/RoostingBluebirds
27.1171494 N Lo -82.4124222 W
He who ask a question is stupid for five minutes, He who never
ask a question remains stupid forever, Chinese Proverb.
From: CookinMedic"at"aol.com
Date: Mon, 17 Jun 2002 09:49:11 EDT
Subject: Bluebirds in Purple Martin house
To: BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
...
From: TonyTrz"at"aol.com
Date: Mon, 17 Jun 2002 16:40:35 EDT
Subject: BB's in Purple martin house
To: bluebird-L"at"cornell.edu
Hi!
I had a successful bluebird nesting in my purple martin house
last year. I didn't suspect it was up there until late in the
process. This year I have a pair of tree swallows in there.
I hope some day I'll get purple martins!
Sarah in SE PA
From: "Bill Darnell" bdarnel3"at"bellsouth.net
To: TonyTrz"at"aol.com, bluebird-L"at"cornell.edu
Subject: Re: BB's in Purple martin house
Date: Mon, 17 Jun 2002 15:51:11 -0500
Sarah:
If you don't already have established Martins in your housing,
you very likely will never get any if Bluebirds and Tree
Swallows nest there.
They are so territorial, they fight off the newly arrived Martins.
Once Martins have nested, their "site fidelity" is
so strong, the Blues and TRES can't handle it.
If you really want Purple Martins, provide housing for the
Bluebirds and TRES close by, and keep the holes in the
Martin housing plugged until the EABL and TRES are settled
in their own housing. Bill TN
Hi!
I had a successful bluebird nesting in my purple martin house
last year. I didn't suspect it was up there
...
Date: Tue, 18 Jun 2002 17:53:46 -0500
To: BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
From: Kate Oschwald bbnestbox"at"1starnet.com
Subject: Re: Bluebirds in Purple Martin house
At 09:49 AM 6/17/02 -0400, CookinMedic"at"aol.com wrote:
I have bluebirds nesting in my Purple Martin Condo. Has anyone
heard
or seen of this before?
C. Rondeau
Gloucester, VA
The first bluebirds I ever saw nested in a martin house on
my property in Lufkin, TX (100 mi north of Houston). A pair
nested there every year until we sold the property. I knew nothing
about monitoring, but would observe the house through binoculars,
and saw baby birds every year. The martin house was not really
in a good martin location, and I never saw a single martin.
Kate Oschwald
Paris, TX
100 mi NE of Dallas
33.6853N 95.6293W
Date: Tue, 3 Jun 2003 07:08:56 -0700 (PDT)
From: The Doctor sytyf"at"yahoo.com
Subject: Two things I haven't seen before
To: BLUEBIRD BLUEBIRD-L"at"cornell.edu
Hey all,
An EABL is nesting in the same house with Purple Martins in
Illinois. The Purple Martin colony is 5 years old.
In NY, TRES are nesting in nestboxes only 20 feet apart...
the TRES spend alot of time staring at each other but they
continue to go about their nesting activities.
Bob Sitarski ...
From: Michelle Martin
Sent: Saturday, January 24, 2004 8:43
Subject: bluebirds vs purple martins
Michelle Martin
Central Louisiana
Can anyone help me on the topic of purple martin housing vs bluebird housing
? A really good friend of mine in Tx has bluebirds and pm's.
Just as I do - well, I let her know that some pm's have been
reported in Tx -did she have her house up yet? She didn't
, but she did put it up that day , and now her blues have been
going in & out of the pm house. And they've been going to
her bb box as well. She asked me about this , if one species
can deter the other from nesting/fighting/etc, and I tried
finding some info on this particular situation...for the
both of us ! Well, I found this link -it's about tri-habitat
for TR/BB/PM's, which of course neither of us have ts nesting
in our area, only get them in winter,what do you all think
of this and what can you add ? www.drugfreeworkplace.com/~Dan/TRIHABITATION/TSEMERGENCY.html
We both would like info quickly b4 the bb's get too use to
the pm house!!!!! Please help us if you can. We are wondering
if we really have to close up the pm house when we know pm's
have been seen in or near our areas already , but neither
of us have seen them ourselves yet. What do we do as far
as how far apart the housing really should be - close up
the pm house even after the pm's arrive, we want both, but
my choice is BLUEBIRDS, and not sure what her's would be
IF we really had to choose ! Any advice ?????????
From: Bet Zimmerman, ezdz"at"charter.net
Sent: Sunday, January
25, 2004 8:45 AM
Subject: RE: bluebirds vs purple martins
I
have read about bluebirds nesting in purple martin houses,
and getting killed by starlings there (because the entrance
holes are bigger than regular bluebird nestboxes). So that
would be my biggest concern. Maybe if she put up some bluebird
boxes also, the blues would gravitate towards them (esp.
Peterson's which bluebirds seem to prefer)? Bet from CT
From: Tony Berg, w1vah"at"yahoo.com
Sent: Sunday, January
25, 2004 12:12 PM
Subject: RE:bluebirds
vs purple martins
If the martin house has been used by martins
before, it should probably be modified to use SREH entrances
to keep out starlings. See www.purplemartin.org/forumarchives/archive/SOPEH.htm.
The SREHs may keep out EABLs as well. Tony Berg
From: Paula, PaulaZ"at"columbus.rr.com
Sent:
Friday, April 02, 2004 12:44 AM
Subject: Re: Also new to list
Mary Ellen,
If it were me, the very first thing I would do would be to
gently lower the box and plug up every single remaining hole
in the martin house. Now that you have bluebirds in there,
they will not allow martins to nest AND you don't want house
sparrows or starlings trying to nest in any of the remaining
cavities. We had our first bluebird nest in a martin house
years ago and the house sparrows killed the babies.
If the hoisting mechanism is too shaky, you might want to
just keep an eye on them after that. You will see mom and dad
enter and leave the nest. If they keep doing this, things are
probably OK. You also might consider just lowering the house
to eye level (when you plug up those remaining holes) so you
can easily monitor and leave it there. Now you can easily take
a peek about once a week, preferably when mom is off the nest.
I do not know
whether leaving box in lowered state could possibly cause
them to abandon nest? Question for others out there?
Paula Z, Powell (Central) Ohio
From: Dottie Roseboom, rosedot"at"mtco.com
Sent: Friday, April 02, 2004 6:57 AM
Subject: Re: Also new to list
Mary Ellen, Paula, According to the experiences of purple martin
landlords that I have read/heard about, purple martins do NOT
mind if the box is lowered 6 - 8" per day, until it is positioned where
needed. Have never
heard if this would also work with bluebirds. However, Blues are very
adaptable creatures. The BIG problem with purple martins, is when monitoring,
newbies raise the box to face a different direction (i.e. northwest instead of
north), and parents enter the wrong apartment.
So, Mary Ellen,
IF you decide to lower the box, try not to change the orientation. From Mary
Ellen's post, I wasn't sure if the post raised/lowered vertically, or if the
middle hinge allowed the top to fold down to the ground. The latter
would provide more difficulties in this situation and Mary Ellen may just have
to hope for the best. In my area, if purple martin houses are not
ACTIVELY monitored, they are overtaken by HOSP. That's why The Purple
Martin Association frowns upon any setup that does NOT allow proper monitoring. Hopefully,
Mary Ellen lives in an area devoid of HOSP. If the
sparrows do begin to harass the bluebirds, contact some of this list's
members privately on ways to handle. Either way, this will be a learning
experience.
Dottie Roseboom, Peoria IL (central)
From: Trish Culpepper [mailto:trishkcully"at"earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, May 11, 2005 11:36 AM
Subject: Re: TRES Starvation
Trish Culpepper - Frankston, TX
Hi Paula! We have put up two Purple Martin houses this spring, but have yet
to see a purple martin. We have, however, cleaned out two HOSP nests out of
one of them so far...one had eggs in it, which we destroyed also. The
houses are in the open, up high, with baffles on them....and we are about a
block from a huge lake. Anyone have suggestions on attracting Purple
Martins?
From: Tree Greenwood [mailto:doctree"at"crosslink.net]
Sent: Thursday, May 12, 2005 1:27 PM
Subject: Egg shells (was "Re: TRES Starvation, ne: Attracting Purple Martings")
Trish, eggs shells aren't used in the nest but they're valuable for almost all nesting birds.
Since they don't have teeth, birds need grit to help grind their food as an early step in their digestion. Female birds also need calcium to lay viable eggs with strong shells. Egg shells give them both. So please do save your egg shells; wash them, dry them, crush them and put them out on an open feeder or just spread them on your driveway.
Or take the easy route and buy 'grit' (crushed oyster or other shells) for your birds. You can buy a 50 pound bag that'll last a lifetime for under $10 at a local farmer's coop or you can buy parakeet grit at the pet store or Wal-Mart.
Same stuff. It's good for digestion but the calcium in store-bought grit isn't as easily absorbed for egg production as egg shells.
Putting out a source of grit and calcium is good for almost all birds.
Take care,
R J 'Tree' Greenwood
Catlett VA
From: Dottie, Hickory Hollow, Brown County, Indiana [mailto:yumyumkatts"at"voyager.net]
Sent: Thursday, May 12, 2005 2:25 PM
Subject: Re: Egg shells (was "Re: TRES Starvation, ne: Attracting Purple Martings")
Before you put out egg shells, you should put them in the microwave or oven
first to kill salmonella.
Dottie, Hickory Hollow
Brown County, Indiana
From: Bruce Burdett [mailto:blueburd"at"verizon.net]
Sent: Tuesday, May 24, 2005 6:24 PM
Subject: Re: ? Using PM house for BBs
LnL,
I believe that Purple Martins are in very short supply these days in our neck of the woods. I haven't seen any of them nesting in a long time, and everyone around here tells me that they've disappeared. Maybe those pesky Bluebirds drove them out.
Has any of you heard of seeing Purple Martins in the New England area lately.
I do gather that they're still nesting in other parts of the country, however.
Bruce Burdett, SW NH
From: Dottie, Hickory Hollow, Brown County, Indiana [mailto:yumyumkatts"at"voyager.net]
Sent: Friday, June 24, 2005 7:11 PM
Subject: Re: ? Using PM house for BBs
Purple Martin landlords here have had a bad spring season with their
Martins.
Many are just falling out of the nest gourds and dying on the ground even
tho the landlords are trying to feed crickets and mealworms.
However, Martins are still coming up North so they are refilling the spots
left by the dead Martins. No eggs yet but nesting has begun so eggs can't
be far behind.
As for me, I haven't even seen a Martin feather at my place and my gourds
look awfully lonely. I'm still playing the Dawn Song every day and
watching the sky.
Dottie, Hickory Hollow
Brown County, Indiana
From: Tree Greenwood [mailto:doctree"at"crosslink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, May 24, 2005 8:23 PM
Subject: Re: ? Using PM house for BBs On Tue 24 May 2005 at 15:07, Trish Culpepper <trishkcully"at"earthlink.net> wrote:
> I had an idea that, since I have a 16-compartment PM house on a
> telescoping pole with baffle that is still vacant (I put them up too
> late for this year, I think), and BBs like a height of 5' or so, why
> don't I lower it to about that height and see if BBs will use it.
Trish, if you want to start a Purple Martin colony, you need to leave your house up until after the Martins migrate back south in late-summer/early-fall. After fledging, PUMA parents take their fledglings on tours around the area. Most PUMA landlords believe that the parents are helping fledglings shop around for next year's breeding spot. If you add some roosting rods (I just use bamboo garden stakes), it's likely that you'll be able to enjoy groups of Martins visiting a bit later this summer.
> ... Luckily, so far, HOSP haven't been interested in it either. ...
That's unusual. HOSP generally like the elevation.
> ... I could always clean it out and raise it back next Jan or Feb in
> time for the PMs arrival. Or do I need to leave it vacant for the PM
> scouts to see all summer, so hopefully they will come next year. Any
> advice or comments?
You folks down south have a much easier time establishing a colony that those of us farther north but you also have more problems with predators. Get great information that is accurate and up-to-date from the Purple Martin Conservation Association at http://www.purplemartin.org/ Start by reading the info in the 'download center' at the bottom of their home page. You may inadvertently do something to discourage PUMA from making your home theirs.
Take care,
R J 'Tree' Greenwood
Catlett VA
From: Lynn Emerich [mailto:lemerich"at"epix.net]
Sent: Tuesday, May 24, 2005 9:20 PM
Subject: Re: ? Using PM house for BBs
They normally do nest in my area but I haven't really been checking the local houses. I'll make it a point to look next time I go by. One guy near hear has/had close to 500 martins a few years ago.
Lynn near Bernville PSW
From: Tree Greenwood [mailto:doctree"at"crosslink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, May 25, 2005 4:43 PM
Subject: Purple Martins in New England (was "Re: ? Using PM house for BBs")
Hi, Bruce.
Actually, the cause was natural according to most experts. In 1972, Hurricane Agnes - "The Storm That Would Never End" - moved across Florida, then moved into the Atlantic. Instead of moving east, Agnes came back ashore in New York on 20 Jun 1972 and then stalled over Pennsylvania where much of the state got over 10" of rain between 20 and 25 Jun. A low pressure system moving across the country then merged with the remnants of Agnes and crept northeast. The whole area from Pennsylvania through Maine was innundated. Many areas had record rainfalls and record floods.
Purple Martins are obligate aerial insectivores.
The constant rains lasting longer than a week caused widespread starvation of Purple Martin colonies throughout the northeast. With no young fledged and virtually no surviving adult PUMA with fidelity to sites there, the Purple Martin population in the northeast still hasn't recovered after three decades.
> Has any of you heard of seeing Purple Martins in the New England area
> lately. ...
Purple Martin populations are SLOWLY recovering but not one has been reported in New Hampshire so far this year. There are some reports of PUMA as close at Vermont and numbers are increasing noticeably in Pennsylvania and New York. See http://www.purplemartin.org/scoutreport/2005/index.php
> ... I do gather that they're still nesting in other parts of the
> country, however.
> Bruce Burdett, SW NH
Definitely! A few pair actually chose my place.
Officially, the conservation status of PUMA is:
| Some populations are undergoing a long-term decline. Not listed as
| threatened or endangered anywhere. (from AAB site at
|
http://www.birds.cornell.edu/programs/AllAboutBirds/BirdGuide/Purple_Martin_dtl.html)
Purple Martins are listed as "most wanted" by 'The Birdhouse Network' so that data on PUMA nesting can be tracked scientifically. The Purple Martin Conservation Association (PMCA) also has on-going research on many facets of PUMA conservation including cooperative work with peer conservation groups in Brazil.
See http://www.purplemartin.org/
Bruce, if you have the time and inclination, the recovery of the Purple Martin in the northeast has crept to your doorstep. If your habitat is suitable for PUMA, putting up and managing some PUMA housing might help the recovery process.
Be warned that it's more and harder work and more expensive than Bluebirds with much less likelihood of early success. It's also every bit as rewarding, if not more so.
Take care,
R J 'Tree' Greenwood
Catlett VA
From: Bet Zimmerman [mailto:ezdz"at"charter.net]
Sent: Wednesday, May 25, 2005 5:43 PM
Subject: purple martins in NE
I believe purple martins (which are listed as threatened in CT) have been nesting in Pomfret and
Stonington, CT
Bet from CT
From: Chuck Jensen [mailto:cjensen"at"dts9000.com]
Sent: Thursday, May 26, 2005 8:35 AM
Subject: FW: Purple Martins in New England (was "Re: ? Using PM house for BBs")
Tree, very interesting recount of the history and how long lasting effect that a devastating loss can have at the edge of a migrants range. This is Scout Report from Maine for this year, so they are flying by NH. With a good location and persistence, its reasonable to expect eventual success. Of course, the Maine report is for very few birds compared to southern states, but then, not every bird is reported. This report came from the Purple Martin Conservation Association website forum at http://www.purplemartin.org/forum/viewforum.php3?f=2. Go to Scout Report and click on your state and it'll give the arrival date and city throughout your state for the first PMs of the year.
An excellent forum. Some socializing but lots of good information. Personal opinion--if you like BBs, you'll love PMs.
Sort by: City Date Name Check out the 2005 Subadult Male Arrivals
CITY DATE NAME
Central Blissville (25 miles SE of Fredericton) 04 May 2005 Gabriel Knorr Lower Cambridge 03 May 2005 Duncan Campbell Haneytown (near Oromocto) 26 April 2005 John Jones wickham 22 April 2005 walter ferris Patterson Settlement 19 April 2005 Name Withheld gagetown 19 April 2005 Tom Scovil Nackawic (30 miles west of Fredericton) 18 April 2005 Andrew Cronkite
Chuck
From: Dottie, Hickory Hollow, Brown County, Indiana [mailto:yumyumkatts"at"voyager.net]
Sent: Thursday, July 14, 2005 11:35 AM
Subject: O/T Purple Martins
I have sad news about my Martin eggs or babies. After not seeing the mom and pop Martins for two days when the rain came, we checked the Martin house yesterday and discovered an empty nest.
As reported earlier, the housing the Martin pair wanted to nest in was an aluminum Martin house that had been converted from 12 compartments to 6 compartments measuring 6" X 12" deep.
Since the wind last winter had bent the double steel pole when it was down, we were not going to put the housing up due to it being very hard to work with a bent pole.
However, since the Martin pair seemed determined to take that housing, we finally managed to get it up 3/4 the way up. They started nesting immediately and, the last time we looked in the housing, they had four eggs. We don't know why they wanted this housing instead of the several gourds complete with pine needles and mud on a really nice and easy to manage pole. ???
We don't know what happened to the eggs or babies. (I figured it was time for the eggs to have hatched.) Since the nest was about 8" in the back of the compartment, we don't see how an animal, hawk or owl could have reached them.
The nest was undisturbed and we could find no eggs or babies on the ground under the pole or anything else that looked suspicious.
I was always a little concerned about the pair being away from the colony and by themselves but a few of the other colony Martins would visit the pair almost daily.
As you can imagine, we are sorry this happened after waiting four years to get Martins and as we have been enjoying our pair for several weeks now and were looking forward to seeing the babies.
On a positive note, some of the other colony Martins are still coming over and flying all around the gourd rack so, hopefully, they will return to nest here next season.
Dottie, Hickory Hollow
Brown County, Indiana
From: Trish Culpepper [mailto:trishkcully"at"earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2005 1:39 PM
Subject: Three Bluebirds Checking Out Nest Box
Trish - East Texas
This morning, after feeding mealworms to the EABLs, I noticed three of them on the Purple Martin House checking it out, peeking in the different compartments. Do EABLs check out possible roosting &/or nesting boxes for use during the next season? Since I never saw a PM all spring/summer, I would love to have the EABLs move in and nest or even roost for the winter since they are around here all year.
From: roy pischer [mailto:tlp4456"at"msn.com]
Sent: Sunday, March 19, 2006 12:29 PM
Subject: Purple Martins
Hello Bluebirders! I wanted to let you know that one pair of our Purple Martins have returned to our farm. I was helping my husband put up horse fence yesterday and saw a lone female flying over the horse paddock. We quickly put up our gourd rack. This morning at 9 AM, saw the female perched on and soaring around the rack. At 11 AM today, I saw a male Purple Martin. We installed "Starling Excluder Doors" on the gourds that we got from the PMCA The Purple Martins don't seem to be unduely stressed by this change from the Starling Resistant half-circle and oboround doors we had last year. FYI, I watched a Starling wiggle into gourds with both these types of "Starling Resistant Doors" last year. It kicked out two eggs and killed one Purple Martin. We set up a "scarecrow" and that kept the EUST away from our gourds for the rest of the summer, but not willing to rely on a scarecrow alone this year.
I called my "Purple Martin Mentor" neighbor, who told me that he put his gourds up last week and immediately 3-4 Purple Martins showed up. He speculated that the very warm weather of the past two weeks encouraged them to move north faster. With temps predicted in the 20's tomorrow night, he thought they might fly back south. Any thoughts on this? I don't have one of the Purple Martin mealworm tray feeders, any suggestions on putting mealworms out for them?
Trudy Pischer
Willard, MO
From: mtalentino"at"alltel.net [mailto:mtalentino"at"alltel.net]
Sent: Saturday, April 08, 2006 1:01 PM
Subject: purple martins
interestingly enough, the purple martins, contrary to popular belief, do not eat mosquitos.
Mike Talentino
Twinsburg, OHIO
From: "Torrey" <torrey_canyon"at"yahoo.com>
Sent: Monday, April 10, 2006 1:03 PM
Subject: OT: another mosquito eater
> Another major mosquito predator is the "mosquito
> hawk", or dragonfly.
>
> All dragonflies & damselflies have to lay their eggs
> in or around water, but the adults of larger species
> will often have feeding territories a good ways inland
> before or after breeding. I commonly see darners when
> i'm half a mile or more from the nearest water.
>
> The aquatic young, sometimes called "water dragons",
> are just as voracious as the adults & will control
> populations of mosquito larvae. They are very
> sensitive to water quality & may take up to 4 years to
> get big enough to become an adult.
>
> Torrey Wenger
> Kalamazoo Nature Center
> Kalamazoo, MI
From: Dottie, Hickory Hollow, Brown County, Indiana [mailto:yumyumkatts"at"voyager.net]
Sent: Monday, April 10, 2006 3:39 PM
Subject: Re: O/T another mosquito eater
There is controversy about whether Martins eat butterflies but they will
definitely get the big and beautiful dragonflies.
I have an overabundance of butterflies here normally (I'm a butterfly
person also) but I have not seen any Martins getting any of the butterflies.
I have a neighbor's Martins to come and eat here twice a day but not the
butterflies. Not yet, anyway. But I do have a lake so maybe that is what
is saving the butterflies as the Martins seem to prefer eating over the
lake.
Dottie, Hickory Hollow
Brown County, Indiana
From: Jim Koehler
Sent: April 11, 2006
RE: ANother mosquito eater
Yes, I agree on this being a very good mosquito catcher as well. This is also another reason I don't cultivate having purple martins around, because they eat a large number of dragon flies!
Jim Koehler
Miltona, MN
From: Keith & Sandy Kridler [mailto:txbluebirder"at"sbcglobal.net]
Sent: Tuesday, May 02, 2006 8:37 AM
Subject: Purple Martins and predators at San Marcos Texas
Keith Kridler Mt. Pleasant, Texas
On the way home from San Antonio I visited with a man who has 485 compartments up for Purple Martins and had 285 nesting pairs last year and already has over 200 nests this spring. We talked of predators he has seen and he had actually killed a large rat snake that very morning in the middle of his martin colony. (He killed two "little" ones only three or four feet long a couple of weeks ago.) He has seen Road Runners fly up on the tops of his nestbox complexes and reach in and remove baby or adult Purple Martins.
He always has a shotgun loaded nearby for Starlings which he says kill more Purple Martins than any other predator.
Owls, hawks and crows are a problem. While I was standing there a Cooper Hawk streaked through so fast and so close to my head I jerked back fearing it would hit me. It missed a martin and ripped down through the martin houses with talons outstretched till about eye level and then it raised up it's killing gear and beat the air furiously with it's wings, dodging a couple hundred now very angry Purple Martins. It was like standing in the middle of a swarm of huge black honey bees. Within seconds the swarm moved off and was gaining altitude faster than the Cooper Hawk as it was constantly now under strafing runs from fighter pilots who had gained the higher altitude. It disappeared in mere seconds into a stretch of woods!
When I looked around this old gentleman who could barely walk minutes before had already sprinted across the entire yard and was heading into the house leaving me standing in the hot noon day sun. He called over his shoulder, "Enjoyed our visit but I got to take care of my birds now! I had told him I "might" stop back by on my way home and he had been sitting in a chair since 5:30 AM waiting for me and ready and loaded for any Starlings that might appear and bother "his" birds. None did that morning. KK
From: Herb Kelley [mailto:herbsho"at"centurytel.net]
Sent: Wednesday, May 17, 2006 2:42 PM
Subject: Dead Purple Martins
Found two dead Purple Martins today.
One in their nest, the other on the ground.
No signs of Trauma on either bird.
An unusual event at least to me.
Given, the issues with virus, what are your thoughts.
Thanks
Herb Kelley
East Central Missouri
From: Robert Barron [mailto:rebarron"at"gmail.com]
Sent: Wednesday, May 17, 2006 3:19 PM
Subject: Re: Dead Purple Martins
Hi Herb,
That doesn't make for a good day at all. I'm sorry to hear about your
loss. Were they both adults? There is no evidence of Avian Flu
anywhere in the western hemishphere yet. I would suspect that they ate
an insect recently sprayed with an insecticide.
Are other PM's nearby ok? What is the weather like. What part of the
country are you in and are other PM landlords experiencing similar
losses. Tell us more.
Thanks,
Rob Barron
From: Herb Kelley [mailto:herbsho"at"centurytel.net]
Sent: Wednesday, May 17, 2006 3:38 PM
Subject: Re: Dead Purple Martins
Thanks for the quick response.
The weather here has been unseasonably cool and wet.
The house are located on a golf course and the grounds keeper says that
he has not changed the chemicals he has used in the past five years.
One local opinion is that they may have starved to death since the
flying insects have not been flying given the weather.
I have some problem with that reasoning simply because the days have
not been many and it has not rained all day every day. Maybe these
were marginal birds that could not handle the stress.
Anyway the state conservation said that they have received several calls
on this issue.
Thanks again.
Herb Kelley
From: Dottie, Hickory Hollow, Brown County, Indiana [mailto:yumyumkatts"at"voyager.net]
Sent: Wednesday, May 17, 2006 4:42 PM
Subject: Re: Dead Purple Martins
Purple Martin landlords here are having Purple Martins to die because they
can't find enough food with all the bad weather. Most landlords are
flipping crickets and it's helping some.
Dottie, Hickory Hollow
Brown County, Indiana
From: Dottie, Hickory Hollow, Brown County, Indiana [mailto:yumyumkatts"at"voyager.net]
Sent: Wednesday, May 17, 2006 4:44 PM
Subject: Purple Martins Starving
This is in our Indy Star newspaper. I get it on-line and it just came over.
Some southern Indiana birds starving
ODON, Ind. -- Recent cool, wet weather that has reduced insect populations appears to be causing large numbers of purple martins in southern Indiana to starve to death.
Dottie, Hickory Hollow
Brown County, Indiana
From: Torrey [mailto:torrey_canyon"at"yahoo.com]
Sent: Thursday, May 18, 2006 6:18 PM
Subject: Re: Dead Purple Martins
Hi Herb,
For future reference, there's a simple way to tell if an otherwise unmarked dead bird possibly died of starvation.
When you're holding the bird, feel for the keel.
(This would be the breast bone in a chicken or
turkey.) This is where all the flight muscles attach.
If the bird was starving, the keel will be a very pronounced, almost sharp ridge. If the bird was otherwise healthy, the keel will be buried by the muscle tissue & much harder to feel. (I don't ever "feel up" healthy birds, so i can't describe how that feels very well.)
Purple Martins feed exclusively on the wing & flying is an energy-intensive activity. The weather doesn't have to be totally rotten (considering wind, rain, &
temperature) to be fatal to marginal individuals.
It's times like this that i'm very glad i get my food from a grocery store. It's tough being dependent on the weather.
Torrey Wenger
Kalamazoo Nature Center
Kalamazoo, MI
From: roy pischer [mailto:tlp4456"at"msn.com]
Sent: Wednesday, July 19, 2006 9:24 PM
Subject: Purple Martin question
Today, the six Purple Martins fledged from the Last of 6 gourds that were successfully nested and fledged babies. Tonight (while trying to salvage what the drought and my horses have left of my zinnias) I noticed that the PM were "bickering" with each other, and would drive some of the newly fledged babies to the tops of the trees in our yard. I saw the same thing with the other groups of fledglings, but paid particular attention tonight. Is this normal behavior? I've never noticed it before.
We had 37 total Purple Martins fledged from our gourds, and the best news yet, after putting PMCA Starling Excluder Doors on our gourds, not a single EUST bothered our PM all summer! Earlier this spring, before the PM arrived, I saw some EUST try to wiggle in the gourds, but they were unsuccessful! The EUST excluder doors are amazing! We fought EUST from our gourds all summer last year, resorting to a scarecrow and 22. Both worked.
From: Kenny [mailto:kpkmajk"at"cox.net]
Sent: Thursday, July 20, 2006 8:52 AM
Subject: RE: Purple Martin question
Hello, Roy. I know enough about bluebirds to be dangerous but purple martins are my real passion. Martin parents work in varying degrees to discourage their fledges from returning to roost in the nesting compartments. This will go on for about a week or two (at the most) before the fledges are more independent and frequent the natal site less and less. Naturally, the fledges have to be “taught” or “encouraged” to roost in trees.
You know, there is a chance that those excluder entrances cause damage to the back feathers of martins enough, that I worry that it could compromise their migration flight efficiency and ultimately, their survival. They do not molt until they are in South America. There needs to be more research on this possibility and I wish PMCA would cause that to happen. Down here in Louisiana, I use excluders only until the young hatch. I use Trio houses where the doors can be interchanged. Eighty percent of the entering and exiting of nesting compartments occurs during the feeding phase and by that time, the starling pressure has all but abated as the starlings have left and found other nesting sites by that time.
Good luck,
Kenny Kleinpeter
Baton Rouge, LA
|